|“||Good luck, Emily. You take care of your mama.||”|
—Scott Shelby to the sleeping Emily
When Jeremy was murdered by the Origami Killer, Mr. Bowles left to complete the trials, unbeknownst to his wife and daughter. Susan subsequently plunged into a deep depression, unable to properly care for Emily, and attempts suicide by slitting her wrists in the bathtub. Private investigator Scott Shelby visits her with the intent of questioning her, and saves her life by treating her wounds. Afterward, Scott offers to take care of Emily by changing her diaper, feeding her warm milk, and rocking her to sleep. If the player successfully cares for Emily without making any mistakes, the player receives the Baby Master trophy.